Keep Market Street open
City Hall wants to replace the Market Street car lanes with bike lanes. Everyone I talk to thinks this is a terrible idea. The council member pushing it doesn’t even own a car, so of course she wants to punish drivers. If we give up these lanes, next they will close the whole centre to cars and the shops will die. Either we keep the lanes or we let downtown turn into a ghost town. Real residents deserve better than this radical experiment.
FallacyAppeal to majority0.86
Everyone I talk to thinks this is a terrible idea.
How many people agree is offered as the reason, not anything about the lanes themselves.
Classifier · Span tagger
FallacyAd hominem0.91
doesn’t even own a car, so of course she wants to punish drivers.
Attacks the council member’s circumstances and motive instead of the proposal.
Classifier · Span tagger
FallacySlippery slope0.88
next they will close the whole centre to cars and the shops will die.
A chain of worse outcomes is asserted, with no step shown to follow from the one before.
Classifier
FallacyFalse dilemma0.84
Either we keep the lanes or we let downtown turn into a ghost town.
Only two outcomes are offered; shared lanes, a trial period or other changes are left out.
Classifier · Wording rule
TechniqueLoaded language0.72
radical experiment
The label carries the judgement, so the reader is asked to reject the plan before weighing it.
Span tagger